Why an Hourly Wage Shouldn’t Apply to Musicians Performing Live

When hiring a musician for a live performance, some clients may think an hourly wage is the most reasonable form of payment. After all, the musician will be physically present for a set number of hours, similar to other types of work. However, this approach fails to acknowledge the unique skills, preparation, and factors involved in live music performance. Like many specialized professions, musicians bring more to the table than just their time—charging them by the hour undervalues the total package they provide. Here’s why an hourly wage model doesn’t work for musicians performing live.

Expertise

Musicians, like plumbers or other skilled professionals, are not only being paid for the time they spend at an event. They’re being compensated for their expertise, talent, and years of practice that allow them to deliver high-quality performances. There’s a popular analogy that highlights this concept: A customer questions a plumber’s hefty bill for fixing a leak in five minutes, to which the plumber responds, “You’re not just paying for the five minutes it took to fix it; you’re paying for the years of experience it took to know how to fix it in five minutes.”

Similarly, musicians have spent years honing their craft to understand what to play, when to play it, and how to adapt their performance to fit the event. Whether it’s knowing how to adjust volume, timing, or the energy level of the performance to match the mood of a wedding, corporate event, or intimate gathering, these decisions are made instinctively by seasoned musicians. The wrong choice in any of these factors can ruin the atmosphere, much like a minor plumbing mistake can disrupt an entire home.

In addition, musicians often have to prepare a wide repertoire of songs to meet the needs of their clients, and that knowledge takes years to accumulate. Hundreds of songs have to be mastered, memorized, and kept ready to perform at a moment’s notice. Expecting an hourly wage to cover this immense preparation time does not adequately reflect the value of a musician’s work.

Unique Style

When hiring a musician, clients aren’t just looking for someone to perform music; they are looking for a particular style or flavor that resonates with their preferences. Musicians, especially those at the top of their craft, have distinct styles that are shaped by their personalities, experiences, and artistic voices. This uniqueness is part of what makes hiring live musicians so special.

As a musician myself, I can confidently say that no one plays in my style better than I do. While I’m not claiming to be the most innovative or original musician, I know that the Dennis Winge style is something that no one else can deliver. When clients hear samples of my performances and decide to hire me based on that style, they are paying for something completely unique to me. This individuality is something no other musician can replicate, making my service valuable beyond the hours I spend at the event.

A great musician knows how to read the room, adjust the tempo, tone, and energy of the music to perfectly match the event’s needs, even if it’s background music. If you’re looking for someone to play interesting, relaxing, and non-invasive background music, it takes years of experience to know how to achieve that balance.

Preparation and Logistics

Another reason musicians shouldn’t be paid by the hour is that much of their time is spent on non-performance activities. Driving to the venue, setting up equipment, sound-checking, and breaking down after the event can add several hours to the job that wouldn’t be covered under an hourly rate. Not to mention the time spent practicing and preparing for the specific songs or mood requested by the client. If clients were paying musicians by the hour, should they also cover the time it takes to dress up for the event or pack up equipment afterward?

If you hire a musician, you’re not just paying for the time they are physically at your event; you’re paying for the professionalism and expertise they bring, which includes everything from logistical preparation to ensuring that the performance aligns with the client’s vision.

Opportunity Cost

An often overlooked factor when considering how to pay musicians is opportunity cost. Musicians typically can only take one gig per evening, especially on peak days like Saturday nights during the summer. If a musician accepts a two-hour gig at a reduced hourly rate, they are losing the opportunity to book another, higher-paying gig on the same night. Unlike other professions where workers can perform multiple jobs in a day or night, musicians usually can’t fit multiple performances into a single evening unless they’re extremely lucky.

Even if an event is shorter than another, the musician has to decline other offers for the same night, which limits their earning potential. For example, if I’m booked for a two-hour event on a prime Saturday night, that’s my one chance for the evening, regardless of how long I perform. If I were paid only for the hours spent playing, I would be undervaluing not just my time but the opportunities I had to turn down.

This is especially true for musicians with wide travel radii. I perform gigs within a three-hour radius of Ithaca, NY, and realistically, I’m only able to take one gig per evening. Occasionally, I might fit in two, but it’s rare. Therefore, if I accept a gig at a lower rate, I risk losing a more lucrative opportunity that could come along later. This opportunity cost is why flat rates are often more appropriate than hourly wages.

Supply and Demand

Supply and demand play a crucial role in the economics of hiring a musician. Certain times of the year, such as summer wedding season or holiday events, are in higher demand, and musicians have a limited number of slots available. Because of this high demand, musicians can and should charge more during peak times.

For example, booking a musician for a Saturday night in July will cost more than booking them for a Monday night in February. The higher rate reflects the value of the musician’s time and the high demand for their services during prime times. On off-peak days, there is more flexibility in pricing, but even then, the musician’s time is limited and valuable.

Conclusion

When hiring a musician, you’re not just paying for the hours they spend performing at your event. You’re paying for years of training, expertise, and the unique style that only they can bring to the occasion. You’re also compensating them for preparation, logistics, and the opportunity cost of not being able to take other gigs.

Music has the power to transform an event, and experienced musicians know how to use their skills to create the perfect atmosphere. Paying them by the hour undervalues the full extent of what they provide. Instead, a flat rate that takes into account all these factors is a more appropriate way to ensure musicians are fairly compensated for the value they bring.

If you’re considering hiring a musician for your next event, remember that what you’re really paying for is the expertise, preparation, and unique artistry that only live music can offer.

—

If you’re planning an event where you’re considering having live music, contact me to book a free music consultation and start planning the perfect soundtrack for it.